Smart Home Privacy Checker insights

Smart bathroom: scale apps dominate data collection, with Google’s app gathering twice as much as the category average

  • Once considered the most private space at home, the bathroom is becoming increasingly connected. From toothbrushes and scales to mirrors, toilets, and showers, smart devices are moving into this intimate room. The analysis identified 20 companion apps associated with these devices. On average, each app collects nine data types, which may include email addresses, phone numbers, location details, and more. This increases users’ exposure to privacy risks.
  • Google Health (Fitbit) and the Official Wyze App rank highest for data collection, gathering 24 and 19 of the 35 data types listed in the App Store, respectively. Both collect well above the smart scale category average of 12, with Google Health (Fitbit) reaching double that number. By contrast, the TOTO In Town Toilet app, a service only available in Japan, collects no data.
  • Smart scale companion apps collect a broader range of data than those for any other smart bathroom device. The Fitbit Aria Air, for example, uses its companion app Google Health (Fitbit) to collect data spanning location details and purchase history to user content and sensitive information. This data may be used not only for app functionality, but also for personalization and other purposes.
  • One in five smart bathroom companion apps engage in user tracking practices. In these cases, collected data may be used for targeted advertising or shared with third parties and data brokers. Four apps were identified with these practices: two linked to smart toothbrushes, one to a smart mirror, and one to a smart scale. Affected devices include the Oral-B iO Series 10, simplehuman Sensor Mirror Hi-Fi, Renpho Elis Nova Smart Body Scale, etc.

Smart kitchen: half of coffee maker apps collect data for tracking, whereas Amazon’s app collects 80% of data types, though not for tracking

  • The kitchen is often the main hub for smart devices in the home. From refrigerators and dishwashers to ranges, kettles, coffee makers, and blenders, smart devices are taking over this everyday space. In total, the analysis identified kitchen devices across 13 categories linked to 47 companion apps, each collecting an average of nine user data types.
  • Amazon Alexa leads smart kitchen apps in data collection, gathering 28 data types — 80% of those listed in the App Store. It serves as the companion app for devices such as the Swan Alexa Smart Kettle and the Hamilton Beach Smart Coffee Maker. At the opposite end, four apps report collecting no data: TempSpike and ChefsTemp for meat thermometers, EKG Updater for a kettle, and Sharp Kitchen for a microwave.
  • Furthermore, 83% of smart kitchen apps collect data tied to user identity. Data collected from an app is often linked to the user’s identity, unless specific privacy protections are put in place before collection to de-identify or anonymize it. Four smart kitchen apps limit their collection to data unlinked to a user’s identity: Breville Commercial HACCP Mgr, Dreo, xBloom Coffee, and SmartThings.
  • Six smart kitchen device categories rank highest by average data collection: ranges, refrigerators, and blenders lead with 12 data types on average, followed by dishwashers, kettles, and coffee makers with 11 each. Some of these categories also include the most data-hungry smart kitchen apps. After Amazon Alexa, at 28 data types, Keurig ranks next with 19 in the coffee maker category, followed by ConnectLife with 17, which appears in both refrigerator and range categories. Owners of products such as the Keurig K-Supreme Plus Smart Coffee Maker and Hisense refrigerators and ranges paired with ConnectLife are among those most exposed to extensive data collection.
  • More than one in four smart kitchen device apps may collect data for tracking purposes. Such practices were identified across most kitchen device categories, except for smart faucets and special cookers. Examples of apps identified as tracking-enabled include LG ThinQ for LG appliances, Xiaomi Home for Xiaomi devices, SmartHQ for GE appliances, and Nespresso Smart for Nespresso products. Tracking was most prevalent in the coffee maker category, where five of the nine apps analyzed reported collecting data for this purpose.

Smart living room: devices pair with companion apps from major tech giants like Apple, Google, and Amazon, with the latter producing the most data-hungry app

  • As the main spot for social gatherings and entertainment, the living room is, by design, the least private space to equip with smart tech. From speakers and TVs to streaming devices, these products now fill our shared areas. Yet the analysis found that 18 identified smart living room apps collect an average of 11 data types each.
  • Smart living room devices across all categories pair with companion apps from major tech companies like Amazon, Google, and Apple. Amazon Alexa leads in data collection, gathering 28 data types for Echo series speakers. The Google Home app follows, collecting 22 data types across devices from speakers to TVs. Google TV ranks third for data collection at 18 data types. By contrast, another Amazon app, Fire TV, collects 8 data types, while Apple Home collects 4.
  • As much as 83% of smart living room apps collect data tied to user identity, except for JBL One, SmartThings, and VIDAA apps. Although Sony | BRAVIA Connect claims to collect data unlinked to user identity, it was excluded due to its disclosures regarding user tracking.
  • One in three smart living room apps (33%) may collect data for tracking purposes. Such practices are prevalent in the TV and streaming device categories, where 40% of analyzed apps engage in tracking. Examples of apps identified as tracking-enabled include LG ThinQ for LG TVs, Sony, ROKU, Sonos for its speakers, and Sky Go for streaming services.

Big Tech, user data, and AI

  • An analysis of the privacy policies from Big Tech companies that offer apps for smart home devices reveals their different strategies for training artificial intelligence. Google and Amazon explicitly acknowledge using user data to develop and improve their AI models and generative services. Apple positions itself differently, stating it does not use personal data for AI model training.
  • Google’s privacy policy states that information collected across its services is used to train its artificial intelligence systems. The company explicitly notes that it uses data about a user’s activity in its services, like interactions with Gemini Apps, “to train and improve machine learning models.”
  • Amazon also acknowledges the use of customer information to advance its technological offerings. According to its documentation, the company uses personal information to develop and improve its services, including “using data to develop or deploy our generative AI models and services.”
  • Apple takes a different legal stance, positioning itself as a provider that does not rely on user data for core model development. Its policy explicitly states that “your private personal data is not used to train our foundational AI models,” emphasizing a focus on smart home data privacy.
  • Microsoft has taken a different route into the home, partnering with LG to embed its Voice Live speech-to-speech agent in the ThinQ ON hub to control home appliances. LG’s privacy policy allows it to use personal information for “artificial intelligence (AI)-related purposes” and share de-identified data with third parties to “enhance AI models.”

Frequently asked questions

Smart home apps, which allow users to control various internet-connected home devices such as TVs, security cameras, and washing machines, raise many privacy concerns. They collect your data, increase your digital footprint, and sometimes use it to display targeted ads. In terms of data security, the risk of data mishandling or leaks may increase as data is distributed across multiple databases.
According to Surfshark’s analysis, various smart home apps collect large amounts of personal data, including your name, contact info, emails and text messages, and even browsing history. Many users are unaware of the extent of data collection and how this data could be shared, used, or sold. Take smart bathroom devices, such as scales and toothbrushes: they are particularly aggressive, with some collecting up to 24 data types, including several used for tracking and personalization.
Smart scales often collect far more data than necessary for basic functionality. According to our research, leading smart scale apps gather up to 24 data types, including location, purchase history, and user content. Some of them share it with third parties such as data brokers or for targeted advertising, personalization, and other purposes.

To safeguard your privacy, review the privacy settings for your smart home apps, grant only the necessary app permissions, turn off unnecessary microphones and cameras, and regularly update the apps.

Beyond these steps, audit which devices you actually need — reducing the number of connected devices in your home is one of the most effective ways to minimize your exposure and overall digital footprint.

Use our Smart Home Privacy Checker to see what data your smart home apps are collecting and secure your smart home devices.

Get in touch

Reach out for any inquiries, feedback, or suggestions regarding our work.

media@surfshark.com
Copied!